Councilwoman's Residency Questioned in Doylestown

Marlene Pray has moved out of the political ward she was elected to represent.

Define temporary.

That is at the heart of a debate over the home address of one member of Doylestown Borough Council.

Marlene Pray has moved out of Ward 1, which she was elected to represent. She says the move is temporary, the result of personal issues.

"I’ve moved into Ward 3, but I remain an elected council person for Ward 1," Pray announced at a council meeting in December 2012. "It is my intention to move back into Ward 1." 

But that is not enough to satisfy one vocal critic of Doylestown Borough Council.

Richard Schoenkopf, who lives on East State Street, has demanded that Pray step down.

"Ms. Pray, out of consideration for first ward residents, should resign," Schoenkopf, 83, said at a recent borough council meeting.

"Her house didn’t burn down, did it?" Schoenkopf demanded.

"No, my family did," Pray responded from the dais.

Schoenkopf, who has previously called for all nine members of council to resign en masse, threatened unspecified legal action over Pray's move.

"Have you signed a lease in your neighborhood?" Schoenkopf asked Pray. "If I have to file a lawsuit, I’ll file a lawsuit."

Mayor Libby White told Schoenkopf that Pray's move was not made by choice.

"That is a hardship," White said, "and it may be a heartbreak, as well."

Though Doylestown Borough encompasses only about 2 square miles, it is divided into three political subdivisions. Each ward elects three members to borough council.

Pray won election in November 2011, representing Ward 1, which included her home on Forest Drive. But personal issues forced her to leave the home recently.

Pray said Monday that she initially looked for a rental in Ward 1 but couldn't find anything she could afford. After being assured that temporarily moving out of her ward would not pose a problem, she moved with her young son to a rental home she owns near the SEPTA station. It is in Ward 3, one-third of a mile from the boundary with Ward 1.

"My family fell apart, I went through a separation, and I am living where I can afford to live right now, as a single mother," Pray told Patch.

While candidates for borough council must must have lived in their ward for at least a year before filing nominating petitions, once elected, the guidelines are vague, says the borough's solicitor.

"Not surprisingly, the general assembly’s language was not clear," said borough solicitor David Conn, when Schoepkopf asked about the legal ramifications of Pray's move. "Temporary relocation does not have any impact."

Doylestown has faced similar issues before.

"Twice in my tenure here we had council people who had the same circumstances and had to temporarily leave their homes," borough manager John Davis said Monday. "The legal advice from our solicitor then, Mr. (Chuck) McIlhinney Sr., was the same as our solicitor's advice now - that it was possible to temporarily relocate without jeapordizing your office."

In fact, another council member faced the same situation and received the same advice in 2010.

"I was going through a divorce and I wasn’t sure I’d be continuing to live in the ward," said Don Berk. "At the time, our solicitor said to me that so long as my intention is to return to the ward, I could continue to represent it, which made a lot of sense to me. Doylestown is only two square miles."

But because Conn and Pray are in a relationship, borough leaders took Conn's advice and started seeking out a second opinion on the matter.

Council president Det Ansinn said Monday he has taken the issue to the Bucks County District Attorney and the state's borough association, with little result.

"I went to the DA for an opinion. The DA has opted not to weigh in," Ansinn told Patch. "Our borough manager asked the Association of Boroughs for an opinion. Their opinion came back completely ambiguous."

As for borough council itself, Ansinn said the governing body has no authority over the service of another member.

"This may be an issue for Marlene and her constituents, but as far as council goes, there’s nothing actionable for us here," Ansinn said.

Pray said Monday that any constituents who want to discuss this or any other issue are welcome to contact her.

"I've gotten four calls in the last week from people in Ward 1 who know that I’m their representative and am taking care of their concerns," Pray said. "I welcome anyone to contact me with any concerns or questions that they may have."

Meanwhile, Pray said she continues to search for a suitable, affordable home in Ward 1.

"I want to move back there, for council, certainly," she said, "but also because I want my son to attend Linden Elementary."

Jeff Lugar February 11, 2013 at 10:35 PM
I'm begging all local media outlets, please stop giving Mr. Schoenkopf any press. Covering complete non-issues like this only encourages him to continue his boorish, obstinate ways. And if he hates council so much, maybe he should run for office.
Jane February 12, 2013 at 12:48 AM
Begging news outlets to bury a story is sketchy, Mr. Lugar. I think that's bad journalistic ethics. (Especially when you work for the media outlet you're recommending hush the story, but didn't disclose that in the comment in which you made the request.)
Jeff Lugar February 12, 2013 at 11:16 AM
Yeah, I haven't worked for a media outlet for a few months. Maybe do a little research next time before running your mouth and stating 'facts' that aren't true. And the story could have been run without giving Mr. Schoenkopf any mention. He just goes to meetings to browbeat people, it looks like. I just hate to see people who don't deserve attention getting it.
Jane February 12, 2013 at 01:39 PM
Interestingly despite your misleading statement that you haven't worked for a media outlet for "months," according to your profile you blogged here at Patch as recently as last week and your profile points to several media outlets for your work. Speaking of "running your mouth" untruthfully. I can see why community-oriented work isn't a good fit for you.
Jody Hansell February 12, 2013 at 04:24 PM
Every citizen has the right to express their opinion. Glad there are still people who are able to do that. Hooray
vonna1 February 12, 2013 at 05:55 PM
I don't understand why this guy is having such a problem with this. I feel empathy for Ms. Pray and wish that she didn't have to deal with this stuff. If this isn't affecting her ability to represent the people in ward 1, this shouldn't be a big problem.
Jeff Lugar February 13, 2013 at 01:16 PM
Blogging here is unpaid. Anyone with a Patch account can do it, and no one gets any money. It's done for fun and community involvement. And my profile cites Twitter (for my tweets), YouTube, (where I've uploaded gaming and dog videos, mostly) and TV.com (where I sometimes blog on pop culture and entertainment, again for free and fun). Are you completely unable to accuse people of things without seeing if you're correct beforehand?
Jeff Lugar February 13, 2013 at 01:38 PM
He's acting like this is Philly, and she represents Olney but has moved to somewhere wholly different like Fishtown or Cobb's Creek.
Jane February 13, 2013 at 02:11 PM
Hey ya blowhard - so you admit you blog under the masthead of this organization. I don't care if it's paid or not. You write for this group, and publicly adjured your editor to bury a story you don't like, without doing so in a manner that forthrightly disclosed your relationship - though it was discernible of course by clicking through to your profile. Your defensive snit is raising my concern further. Sure, write about how you think the story should be silenced on your own private blog. But you have a formal association - paid or not, as if that makes a difference - with this organization. Makes me uncomfortable.
J February 13, 2013 at 02:42 PM
The bottom line is that in politics, you should actually try to represent the area that you represent. I don't care what your personal life is bringing you, get it together. You chose to participate in a divorce, why am I even being INFORMED of this, let alone hearing it used as an excuse. PS, I get a kick out of not being "able to afford" it. Not a bit of pity here. Get back to your district or step down. It isn't hard. And Jeff, it actually is news, who the hell are you to tell anyone what is or isnt?. And I think Mr. Schoenkopf's position shows that he DOES care.
Jeff Lugar February 13, 2013 at 02:48 PM
"publicly adjured?" "bury a story" LOL There's no "story" because it's a complete non-issue and frankly unworthy of attention. A kind public servant moved a few hundred yards temporarily due to her personal setbacks; it's not Watergate.
Jane February 13, 2013 at 02:54 PM
Neither are video game reviews Watergate - if that's your standard does it mean we can hear less from you? But I think the public's right to know and to form their own opinion is highest when it comes to local politics. I don't think that means Marlene should step down, or should be individually hassled in a time that must be filled with great heartache for her, but if a representative has left the borders of the district/ward/town/state etc that elected them, to me, it's news. Lots of local news isn't "Watergate," what a nonsensical standard. "LOL"
Jeff Lugar February 13, 2013 at 03:06 PM
You're no more in position to say it is news than I am to say it isn't. That's why we have comment sections in media sites--so we can all express our opinions. My opinion is that this isn't newsworthy; it's just covering a man harping on a woman who moved a third of a mile due to a temporary issue. I fully trust her ability to still represent Ward 1 no matter where in Doylestown she lives at the moment.
Jeff Lugar February 13, 2013 at 03:21 PM
But she announced the move in December. I'm not sure why Mr. Schoenkopf raising ire two months later suddenly makes it an issue. His saying something shouldn't make it more of an issue; either she was in jeopardy of having to give up her seat or she wasn't. There could have been an article written about the move when it was announced (or if there was, I missed it); waiting until someone who's made a habit of berating council does so yet again just seems like "feeding the troll". That's what bothers me.
J February 13, 2013 at 03:22 PM
That's fine, our opinions differ. But you werent expressing an opinion, you were asking to have his opinion shut down. Anyway as for Ms. Pray, I don't trust her one bit to represent anything whatsoever. I guess I'll just wait and do my part to vote her out of there. Oh and hey, I hear she's single, go for it dude!
Jane February 13, 2013 at 03:44 PM
Are you serious? REALLY?!? Borough council meets on the third Monday of every month, according to DoylestownBorough.net. A quick Google search for the meeting minutes reveals council met on 12/17/12 (adjusted I assume for the holidays) and 1/23/13. The Feb. 11 article suggests he raised his objections at "a recent meeting" and that seems consistent with the meeting dates. A review of the minutes from the 12/17/12 meeting indicates that Ms. Pray made an announcement about her temporary relocation at that meeting. As such, the January borough council meeting was apparently the first meeting at which Schoenkopf had an opportunity to speak to council about the issue. What was that you said? Oh yeah. Maybe do a little research next time before running your mouth and stating 'facts' that aren't true. The research here took me all of 2-3 minutes with Google and given the extent to which Council has apparently endeavored to create great transparency and communication around their meetings.
Jane February 13, 2013 at 03:47 PM
Apologies, that final run-on sentence should have ended "and was very easy, given the extent to which Council has apparently endeavored to create great transparency and communication around their meetings."


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something